Plaintiffs Litigation Blog: Counsel Notes
- All
- Accident and Negligence Claims (36)
- Accident Benefits (3)
- Back, Neck and Spinal Cord Injuries (9)
- Bike / Cycling Accidents (1)
- Brain and Head Injuries (11)
- Burn Injuries (1)
- Car Accidents (9)
- Cartiva SCI (1)
- Chronic Pain (5)
- Civil Sexual Assault Claims (4)
- Class Actions (9)
- Cleroux (1)
- Client Resources (9)
- Commercial Host Liability (1)
- Community Involvement (26)
- Conferences (7)
- Counsel Notes (48)
- Critical Illness Insurance (1)
- Denied Claims (4)
- Disability Insurance (2)
- Dog Bites (2)
- Fibromyalgia (1)
- Fire Loss (3)
- Firm News (6)
- Flood and Theft Claims (1)
- Government Claims (2)
- Homeowners Insurance (3)
- ICBC Part 7 Benefits (2)
- Injured Passengers (3)
- Injury Claims (15)
- Insurance Broker Negligence (2)
- Insurance Disputes (7)
- Legislative Developments (2)
- Medical Malpractice (6)
- Motor Vehicle Accidents - ICBC Injury Claims (7)
- Motorcycle Accidents (1)
- Murphy Battista (4)
- Negligence (3)
- Pedestrian Injuries (2)
- Recreational and Sports Injuries (5)
- Rehabilitation (3)
- Residential and Business Loss Insurance Claims (2)
- School Accidents (1)
- Sexual Abuse (2)
- Sexual Abuse and Misconduct (1)
- Slip and Fall Injuries (1)
- Social Host Liability (1)
- Social Host Liability (3)
- Soft Tissue Injuries (1)
- Sponsorships (15)
- Travel Insurance (1)
- Truck and Commercial Vehicle Accidents (1)
- All
- Annual Sponsorships (1)
- BC Laws (1)
- British Columbia (1)
- Civil Claims (1)
- Co-op Housing (1)
- Co-op Membership (1)
- Co-ops (1)
- Cycle for Sight (2)
- disability travel (1)
- fighting blindness canada (2)
- Golf for Julia (1)
- Halloween (2)
- Housing Cooperatives (1)
- Limitation Act (1)
- Murphy Battista LLP (2)
- para-badminton (1)
- Risk Assessment (1)
- SCI (1)
- SCI BC (1)
- Social Outreach (2)
- Spinal cord injury (2)
- Teen (1)
- traveling with medication (1)
- Vancouver Sun Run (1)
- wheelchair sports (1)
- All
- Alex Sayn-Wittgenstein (2)
- Andrew Brine (2)
- Angela Bespflug (0)
- Bill Dick (4)
- Brandon Souza (3)
- Caitlin Ohama-Darcus (1)
- Irina Kordic (2)
- J. Scott Stanley (12)
- Janelle O’Connor (6)
- Jeffrey J. Nieuwenburg (3)
- Joe Battista (0)
- Joe Murphy (5)
- Keri Grenier (0)
- Kevin Gourlay (47)
- Kevin Hyde (1)
- Kristina Shelden, Resource Coordinator, PIRC (8)
- Kyle Gieni, Resource Coordinator, PIRC (5)
- Matthew Van Nostrand (1)
- Mike Murphy (0)
- Olivia Berumen (0)
- Paul Bosco (4)
- Sean Lynn, Resource Coordinator, PIRC (0)
- Sherman Lam, Resource Coordinator, PIRC (0)
- Tara Chandler (0)
- Valerie Taylor (0)
- Veronica Medved (0)
- Murphy Battista (40)
Accident and Negligence Claims (36)
Back, Neck and Spinal Cord Injuries (9)
Civil Sexual Assault Claims (4)
Critical Illness Insurance (1)
Insurance Broker Negligence (2)
Motor Vehicle Accidents - ICBC Injury Claims (7)
Recreational and Sports Injuries (5)
Residential and Business Loss Insurance Claims (2)
- All
- Annual Sponsorships (1)
- BC Laws (1)
- British Columbia (1)
- Civil Claims (1)
- Co-op Housing (1)
- Co-op Membership (1)
- Co-ops (1)
- Cycle for Sight (2)
- disability travel (1)
- fighting blindness canada (2)
- Golf for Julia (1)
- Halloween (2)
- Housing Cooperatives (1)
- Limitation Act (1)
- Murphy Battista LLP (2)
- para-badminton (1)
- Risk Assessment (1)
- SCI (1)
- SCI BC (1)
- Social Outreach (2)
- Spinal cord injury (2)
- Teen (1)
- traveling with medication (1)
- Vancouver Sun Run (1)
- wheelchair sports (1)
- All
- Alex Sayn-Wittgenstein (2)
- Andrew Brine (2)
- Angela Bespflug (0)
- Bill Dick (4)
- Brandon Souza (3)
- Caitlin Ohama-Darcus (1)
- Irina Kordic (2)
- J. Scott Stanley (12)
- Janelle O’Connor (6)
- Jeffrey J. Nieuwenburg (3)
- Joe Battista (0)
- Joe Murphy (5)
- Keri Grenier (0)
- Kevin Gourlay (47)
- Kevin Hyde (1)
- Kristina Shelden, Resource Coordinator, PIRC (8)
- Kyle Gieni, Resource Coordinator, PIRC (5)
- Matthew Van Nostrand (1)
- Mike Murphy (0)
- Olivia Berumen (0)
- Paul Bosco (4)
- Sean Lynn, Resource Coordinator, PIRC (0)
- Sherman Lam, Resource Coordinator, PIRC (0)
- Tara Chandler (0)
- Valerie Taylor (0)
- Veronica Medved (0)
October 24, 2017
Commercial hosts serving alcohol owe a duty of care to patrons.
This past March, Mr. Justice Kent of the Supreme Court of British Columbia set a new precedent in Widdowson v. Rockwell, 2017 BCSC 385, a summary trial of a commercial host liability claim. Murphy Battista LLP’s Paul Bosco and Joe Battista, Q.C. represented the plaintiff, Stuart Widdowson who was walking…
Continue ReadingSeptember 19, 2017
Car stolen from dealership involved in three collisions causing injuries – dealership 15% liable; plaintiff not contributorily negligent
In the recent and highly unusual case of Provost v. Bolton, 2017 BCSC 1608, Murphy Battista’s Alex Sayn-Wittgenstein and Paul Bosco represented the plaintiff, Richmond RCMP Corporal Quinn Provost, for injuries sustained when a stolen vehicle hit his cruiser during a high-speed chase. Why the case is important This case…
Continue ReadingMay 20, 2016
Laser Hair Removal and Tattoos Don’t Mix

A lawsuit involving a painful burn, alleged to have been caused by laser hair removal over a tattoo, has resurrected an issue regarding the lack of regulation of the laser hair removal industry in BC. Read the CBC story HERE Warning for consumers re: laser hair removal Laser hair removal…
Continue ReadingAugust 4, 2015
What Is A “Reasonable Offer to Settle” – Kostecki v. Li, 2015 BCSC 1356
Reasons today from Mr. Justice Schultes to deal with costs following a trial where the plaintiff was awarded $49,000. The plaintiff had made two formal offers to settle, the first for $45,000 and the second for $30,000, and was seeking double costs. When considering whether to award a successful plaintiff…
Continue ReadingCategories
Counsel NotesSeptember 17, 2014
Road Maintenance Claims — Kelly v. Perth (County)
We frequently act in claims where individuals have suffered injuries as a result of terrible road conditions. Particularly in this country with our weather conditions, perfection in road maintenance is not the standard but the responsible parties must exercise reasonable care in the performance of their duties. The consequences of…
Continue ReadingSeptember 9, 2014
Are You of Good Enough Character and Repute to be a Lawyer?
All lawyers have had to proceed through an interview with a Law Society bencher to determine that they are of sufficient good character and repute to become a lawyer. For most, this is a rubber stamp. For those with checkered pasts, it can become an issue and require a full…
Continue ReadingCategories
Counsel NotesFire Insurance: If Your Tenant Contributes To Insurance, Buy Insurance
If a landlord collects contributions to fire insurance from tenants as part of the lease agreement, the expectation is that fire insurance will be purchased. In reasons released last week, Giddings Holdings Ltd. v. High, 2014 BCSC 1658, an unfortunate landlord failed to insure his building despite the lease including a proportionate…
Continue ReadingSeptember 4, 2014
McCollum, Scalia, and The Death Penalty
Canada abolished the death penalty in Canada in 1976, having last executed a person over 50 years ago (1962). Virtually all of the developed world has done the same. The famous exception is the United States which continues to execute people, trailing only China, Iran, Iraq, and Saudi Arabia in…
Continue ReadingCategories
Counsel NotesAugust 29, 2014
Scienter and Liability for Your Dog
Reasons for judgment recently from Mr. Justice Joyce in Gallant v. Slootweg, 2014 BCSC 1579, involving a plaintiff who broke his clavicle and multiple ribs after being chased and knocked from his bicycle by the defendant’s dog. In the course of the judgment, the Court reviewed and restated the doctrine of…
Continue ReadingAugust 5, 2014
Expert Reports and the Proper Role of Counsel
In a voir dire during a recent jury trial (available here), Mr. Justice Abrioux criticized the practice of experts appending lengthy appendices, particularly those summarizing voluminous clinical records. The criticism makes sense in a jury trial; those clinical records would not otherwise be in the jury room so it defies…
Continue ReadingCategories
Counsel Notes